The Noncontroversial Controversy

So.  This was actually a thing.

It seems that Melissa Harris-Perry cut a "Lean Forward" ad for her employer MSNBC in which she dared to opine that the children of America were collectively everyone's responsibility.  And to some folks on the right (such as, Sarah Palin, Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh just to name a few), that surely meant that she was trying to say that their kids aren't really their kids.  Or that the liberal, elitist, black woman wants to take their their children away.  Or...something.

Here's the "offending" ad:

Of course, as is our right as American citizens, anyone can freely disagree with the gist of what she said.  But to actually think that she was trying to imply (or actually believes) that parents should have no role in their children's lives or that the family unit is superfluous in the raising of their children is absolutely ludicrous. 

I'm all for well-thought-out, reasonable discussions concerning why someone might have a problem with Melissa Harris-Perry's statement, but sorry...Sarah Palin's "Apparently MSNBC doesn't think your children belong to you.  Unflippingbelievable" tweet isn't going to cut it.

Now of course, I was all ready to rant and rave and go off about the sheer ridiculousness of the responses the ad received, but there's no need.  MHP knows very well how to handle herself, and that she did. 


Statement from Melissa Harris-Perry on her MSNBC site:
My inbox began filling with hateful, personal attacks on Monday, apparently as a result of conservative reactions to a recent “Lean Forward” advertisement now airing on MSNBC, which you can view above. What I thought was an uncontroversial comment on my desire for Americans to see children as everyone’s responsibility has created a bit of a tempest in the right’s teapot. Allow me to double down.

One thing is for sure: I have no intention of apologizing for saying that our children, all of our children, are part of more than our households, they are part of our communities and deserve to have the care, attention, resources, respect and opportunities of those communities.

When the flood of vitriolic responses to the ad began, my first reaction was relief. I had spent the entire day grading papers and was relieved that since these children were not my responsibility, I could simply mail the students’ papers to their moms and dads to grade! But of course, that is a ridiculous notion. As a teacher, I have unique responsibilities to the students in my classroom at Tulane University, and I embrace those responsibilities. It is why I love my job.

Then I started asking myself where did I learn this lesson about our collective responsibility to children. So many answers quickly became evident. I learned it from my mother who, long after her own kids were teens, volunteered on the non profit boards of day care centers that served under-resourced children.

I learned it from my father who, despite a demanding career and a large family of his own, always coached boys’ basketball teams in our town.

I learned it from my third-grade public school teacher, who gave me creative extra work and opened up her classroom to me after school so that I wouldn’t get bored and get in trouble.

I learned it from the men who volunteered as crossing guards in my neighborhood even if they don’t have kids in the schools. I learned it from the conservative, Republican moms at my daughter’s elementary school, who gave her a ride home every day while I was recovering from surgery.

I learned it watching the parents of Newtown and Chicago as they call for gun control legislation to protect all the children of our communities.

I learn it from my elderly neighbors who never complain about paying property taxes that support our schools, even if they have no children in the schools today.

And I have learned it from other, more surprising sources as well. I find very little common ground with former President George W. Bush, but I certainly agree that no child should be left behind. And while I disagree with the policies he implemented under that banner, I wholeheartedly support his belief that we have a collective national interest in all children doing well.

I’ll even admit that despite being an unwavering advocate for women’s reproductive rights, I have learned this lesson from some of my most sincere, ethically motivated, pro-life colleagues. Those people who truly believe that the potential life inherent in a fetus is equivalent to the actualized life of an infant have argued that the community has a distinct interest in children no matter what the mother’s and father’s interests or needs. So while we come down on different sides of the choice issue, we agree that kids are not the property of their parents.

Their lives matter to all of us. I believe wholeheartedly, and without apology, that we have a collective responsibility to the children of our communities even if we did not conceive and bear them. Of course, parents can and should raise their children with their own values. But they should be able to do so in a community that provides safe places to play, quality food to eat, terrific schools to attend, and economic opportunities to support them. No individual household can do that alone. We have to build that world together.

So those of you who were alarmed by the ad can relax. I have no designs on taking your children. Please keep your kids! But I understand the fear.

We do live in a nation where slaveholders took the infants from the arms of my foremothers and sold them for their own profit. We do live in a nation where the government snatched American Indian children from their families and “re-educated” them by forbidding them to speak their language and practice their traditions.

But that is not what I was talking about, and you know it.
I venture to say that anyone and everyone should know full well that my message in that ad was a call to see ourselves as connected to a larger whole. I don’t want your kids, but I want them to live in safe neighborhoods. I want them to learn in enriching and dynamic classrooms. I want them to be healthy and well and free from fear. I want them to grow up to agree or disagree with me or with you and to have all the freedom and tools they need to express what they believe.
And no hateful thing that you say to me or about me will ever change that I want those things for your children. (emphasis added is mine)
*MHP drops the mic and walks away*

This woman is a treasure!  She's smart as hell, confidant, and unwilling to be cowed by the bullies on the right.  While a part of me felt that such silliness didn't even deserve a response, I'm glad that she did.  These folks need to know that people are done sitting back and letting them control the conversation all the time.  Especially when what they're adding to it doesn't make a lick of sense.

The reaction to this ad is the kind of illogical lunacy that makes it very clear why the rest of the world thinks that a large majority of Americans aren't very bright.

I find it hard to disagree.


  1. She needs to run for office. At this point, she just needs to run for office. I'll move to wherever she is and register to vote just so I can help put this woman in office.

    1. Seconded.

      This woman could say, "The sun is hot and space is cold," and them same dumb-ass mofos would still argue with her just because. We know good and damn well what MHP was saying.

      I hate people.

  2. I think the funniest part about this whole "controversy" is the fact when bad ish goes down, white America gets so supportive and protective of each other with sayings like; " we are in this together, we have to protect/love/understand/ look out for each other, we must protect our children and their futures by looking after each other" BUT wait didn't y'all just say not to mess with your kids.
    I also think its funny how white people can say don't try to take my kids away especially since back in the day and for some, to this day; they have nannies/housekeepers/babysitters who watch/look after and know more about their kids than they do.
    And please white people, let's not act like you know how it is or how it feels to have your kids taken/snatched from you, so just please stop cuz your ignorance is showing yet AGAIN.


This blog is strictly moderated. Everyone is now able to comment again, however, all Anonymous posts will be immediately deleted. Comments on posts more than 30 days old are generally dismissed, so try to stay current with the conversations.